August 21, 2026 Janine Praxmarer
After dealing with the possibilities and limitations of artificial intelligence in recruiting in the first two parts, I keep coming back to a question: What makes a good recruiter exactly?
Because as AI becomes capable of taking on more and more tasks in the future, we might have to think about what tasks actually constitute the core of our profession. For me, the answer is pretty clear: Recruiting is not just about finding and recruiting candidates. It is primarily about understanding people and companies.
A good recruiter must be able to listen
For me, listening is one of the most important qualities in recruiting. And by that I don’t just mean letting someone talk out their feelings. You really have to listen.
- What does the candidate actually want?
- Why does he want to leave his current employer?
- What is important to him in a new job?
- What does he envision for his workplace?
And sometimes a candidate might say something completely different from what they actually mean. Maybe someone says that they want to develop their career – in the conversation it turns out that they actually want to take on more responsibility. To do that, you have to ask questions, dig deeper, and really get to know the person.
The company must also be understood.
An employment ad may describe a position, but not always the entire work environment. A company may write that it is looking for someone who is team-oriented, flexible, and reliable. But what does that mean in practice? What does the team look like, how does the department operate, how much autonomy is expected, and what is the company culture?
Sometimes when talking with the company, it turns out that the actual requirements profile looks slightly different from the original job description — this is where a recruiter can offer added value.
For me, recruiting is not simply a job search.
Of course, AI can help find suitable profiles. It can analyze resumes and compare criteria. But for me, recruiting is not a mathematical task. It’s not about someone meeting 95 percent of the requirements and therefore automatically being the best person.
Sometimes someone achieves 70 percent and still fits perfectly. And sometimes someone achieves 100 percent and still doesn’t fit. That is one of the biggest differences for me between data analysis and recruiting.
Perhaps AI is even changing the professional image of the recruiter
Perhaps we spend less time on administrative tasks. Perhaps certain processes will become significantly faster. Perhaps AI will become an ordinary tool in everyday recruiting. And perhaps that is precisely why the human part of our work will become more important – because when technology takes over the routine, we can focus more on advice and communication.
This could mean that recruiters will be perceived even more strongly in the future as advisors, not just as someone who searches for candidates, but also as a contact person for companies and for people who want to change their careers.
That's why I don't see AI as a competitor.
I can't say how the technology will develop in five or ten years. But even then, I believe that the question isn't just about what is technically possible. The crucial question is: What do we, as humans, actually want to automate?
Just because AI can theoretically conduct a job interview, that doesn’t automatically mean that a company wants to do so. Perhaps the personal touch is actually part of the company culture – and that could even be a competitive advantage in the future.
What happens if all companies use AI?
When almost every company eventually starts using AI in recruiting, AI may no longer be a particular advantage in itself. Then another question arises: What distinguishes the companies from each other?
Perhaps it is the personal interaction with applicants.
Perhaps it is the speed of the feedback.
Maybe it's a personal conversation.
Perhaps it is the opportunity to talk to a real contact person.
Because when everything is automated and standardized, personal communication can suddenly become something special again.
The recruiter won't disappear – but he needs to evolve
I don't think it makes sense to reject AI fundamentally or to pretend that it doesn't play a role. It will play a role, and probably an increasingly larger one. Therefore, we should learn to use it meaningfully – without eliminating our own experience and judgment.
And above all, we should not forget that behind every application there is a person.
Man and AI is the most sensible combination for me
If I had to summarize the development in one sentence, it wouldn’t be „AI replaces recruiters». For me, it would be more like: AI changes the work of recruiters. And that doesn’t have to be negative.
If AI helps me save two hours of routine work, I can use that time to talk with candidates. If it helps me structure information more quickly, I can focus more on the personal assessment. That’s exactly where I see the added value—not in removing people from the process but in giving them better opportunities to do their actual work.
What does this mean for companies?
It doesn’t have to be about automating as much as possible. What matters more is the question: Which processes can be improved by AI without compromising on quality or personal contact?
Perhaps it makes sense to use AI for search and pre-selection, for administrative tasks, or when creating job ads. But for important conversations with candidates, I would continue to view human contact as very valuable. After all, a hiring decision is not just a matter of data; a company makes a decision based on a person, and a person simultaneously decides for a company.
And what does that mean for applicants?
I believe that staying authentic could become even more important in the future. As resumes and cover letters can be increasingly optimized with AI, the personal personality may perhaps once again take center stage. After all, a perfect cover letter is of little use if you are not authentic in conversation.
My personal conclusion
Personally, I am not afraid that AI will make the recruiter of today obsolete overnight. I believe that our profession will continue to evolve: certain tasks will become easier, others will be automated – and other areas will become more important as a result.
For me, recruiting means not just finding someone whose resume fits a specific open position. It means getting to know people, understanding companies, and finding out whether both sides really align. AI can help us save time and provide information. But the decision about how we interact with people should not be completely automated.
The future of recruiting is not about people or AI. Her name is Mensch and AI. Behind every application is a person — and that should never be forgotten in future recruitment either.
